Which database to choose for logging/analysis feature

Google Cloud Database
,
1

Hello fellow community,

I’m currently evaluating possible databases from the Google Cloud offerings for the implementation of a logging and analysis tool for our web application. From what I found out already it seems that a combination of BigTable and BigQuery could be a good solution but I’m curious if someone would tackle such a scenario differently.

There are two main goals:

  • provide API for our web application to show near-realtime logs data of all our connected devices (similar to google cloud logging UI)
  • provide analysis capabilities based on the received logs data

Currently all devices are sending roughly 50k logs and status messages per day which could easily be doubled when resolution is increased. Also, the current number of connected devices can easily grow high (10-20x) in the future so we will be dealing with a fast growing and big dataset in the future.

The current idea would be to use Pubsub for data ingress and a GCF that perhaps prepares and stores the reveived payloads in BigTable. The BigTable would be used as database to output logging data through an API with minimal query abilities, e.g. time range, type, etc.

Due to insert limitations of BigQuery, we’ll have to implement some kind of service that will slowly feed the BigQuery with the incoming data in BigTable. BigQuery would than be used to provide deeper analytic capabilities for our application.

As alternative, we also think about either using simple Cloud SQL or a MongoDB Atlas cluster as main database which would greatly simplify the setup :grin:

Has somebody already implemented a similar solution and has any pros/cons on this planned setuo? Maybe other solutions that work better?

Cheers and thanks,

Stephan

2

Hello,

I would like to gather some more information.

Are your logs stored on Google Cloud Logging ? If so you can sink directly to BigQuery for data analytics. Otherwise you can consider export your logs to Cloud Logging and from there moving to BQ.

A second approach could be using this architecture

Pub/Sub → Dataflow → BigQuery or BigTable. Including Dataflow could be good since is designed to handle both stream and batch processing.

Here are some use cases as reference:

  1. https://cloud.google.com/architecture/streaming-avro-records-into-bigquery-using-dataflow
  2. https://subscription.packtpub.com/book/virtualization-and-cloud/9781788291996/5/ch05lvl1sec40/creating-a-dataflow-pipeline-to-store-streaming-data
  3. https://subscription.packtpub.com/book/virtualization-and-cloud/9781788291996/5/ch05lvl1sec40/creating-a-dataflow-pipeline-to-store-streaming-data
3

Hello,

thanks for the detailed response. The incoming logs are related to external devices and must be stored and backuped for further analysis using BQ. We have now settled on this architecture: Pub/Sub → CF → Cloud SQL (Postgresql) → BQ.

With this setup we can assure that data is automatically backuped within Cloud SQL service and analysis can be done directly using BQ on Cloud SQL data - if I read the docs correctly :slightly_smiling_face:

I’ll definitely take a look at Dataflow though. Maybe it fits better than a CF in this use-case.

Cheers!

Stephan